This decision dismisses an appeal from a voluntary dismissal with prejudice of plaintiffs’ claims following a trial court order sustaining a demurrer to some, but not all, alleged claims, with leave to amend. It holds that the dismissal is not appealable and neither is the demurrer ruling which did not finally dispose of any alleged claims. Combining the two non-appealable orders does not make either of them appealable. The cases that allow appeals following voluntary dismissals do so after entry of an order finally disposing of at least one cause of action. The decision criticizes Ashland Chemical Co. v. Provence (1982) 129 Cal.App.3d 790 for appearing to allow appeals from voluntary dismissals too liberally.