In McCaskill v. Navient Solutions, 2016 WL 1367228 (M.D. Fla. 2016), here, Judge Covington of the USDC for the Middle District of Florida granted partial summary judgment to a TCPA plaintiff whose cellular telephone received 727 telephone calls to her cellular telephone arising from collection on student loans taken out by her daughter.  Since the defendant bore the burden to prove, but could not demonstrate, consent, the Court granted summary judgment to the Plaintiff.  The Court denied summary judgment on the issue of whether the $500 or $1,500 penalty per call was appropriate.