Southern District says Civ. Code 1788.17’s incorporation of federal law involves no “substantial federal question”
In Murphy v. Triad Financial, Judge Benitez of USDC for the Southern District dismissed a Rosenthal Act claim as lacking federal question jurisdiction. Judge Benitez rejected the argument that since Civil Code § 1788.17 incorporates the federal FDCPA, claims filed under that section trigger federal question jurisdiction under the "substantial federal question" doctrine. The parties "argue that Murphy's Rosenthal Act… Read More